Asesoramiento genético: ¿Una práctica que estimula la eugenesia?

Ricardo Miguel Luque Bernal, Roberto José Buitrago Bejarano

Resultado de la investigación: Contribución a una revistaArtículorevisión exhaustiva

2 Citas (Scopus)

Resumen

Introduction: Genetic counseling can be practiced under four scenarios: preconception, preimplantation, prenatal, and postnatal (which is similar to preconception). Some authors argue that it should be considered a form of eugenics. The aim of this article is to present different views expressed in the literature regarding the relation between genetic counseling and eugenics. Materials and methods: A search of articles was conducted in several academic databases using the MeSH/DeCS terms bioethics, medical genetics, genetic counseling, and eugenics. Articles were included if they discussed eugenics or genetic screening. Articles were excluded if they provided a technical description of procedures. The selection was made after examining titles, abstracts, and full texts. Results: Fifty-seven articles were selected for analysis. In preconception counseling, the “reproductive beneficence principle” can be based on eugenic practices of the early twentieth century. In pre-implantation consultation, the genetic selection of embryos can be considered eugenic when it is used to change the natural course of reproduction or used for non-medical purposes. Prenatal diagnosis, when linked to abortion as a response to congenital malformations, can be considered negative eugenics. Conclusion: At present, eugenics can be defined in multiple ways. By some definitions, genetic counseling can be framed as a eugenic practice. However, the design of health policies and the interests of society may influence the autonomy of individuals. The possibility of generating a genetic selection of individuals, on the other hand, can be constituted as positive eugenics.

Título traducido de la contribuciónIs genetic counseling a form of eugenics?
Idioma originalEspañol
Páginas (desde-hasta)10-26
Número de páginas17
PublicaciónRevista ciencias de la salud
Volumen16
N.º1
DOI
EstadoPublicada - ene 1 2018

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Medicina (miscelánea)
  • Sanidad (ciencias sociales)

Huella Profundice en los temas de investigación de 'Asesoramiento genético: ¿Una práctica que estimula la eugenesia?'. En conjunto forman una huella única.

Citar esto