The Real Winner´s Curse

Juan Fernando Vargas Duque, Leopoldo Fergusson, Alejandro Ruiz-Guarin, Pablo Querubin

Research output: Working paper

Abstract

We study the effect on violence of the arrival of previously excluded groups (in particular,
left-leaning parties) to local executive office in Colombian municipalities. Using a regression
discontinuity approach, we show that while violence from left-wing guerrillas and the government
is unaffected when the left wins mayoral elections, attacks by right-wing paramilitaries
increase by about four to five per 100,000 inhabitants, almost a tripling relative to the sample
mean and close to 80%-100% of a standard deviation. We interpret this increase in violence
as a de facto reaction of traditional political and economic elites trying to counteract the increase
in de jure power of outsiders after they win office. Consistent with this interpretation,
we find that the surge in violence is concentrated in the year of the subsequent elections
and as a result left wing incumbents enjoy an incumbency disadvantage larger than other
incumbent parties in Colombia. We also find (more tentative evidence) that the left implements
land policies that are threatening to the most notorious allies of paramilitaries: large
landowners. These effects highlight the unintended risks of political inclusion in societies
with weak institutions, an uneven presence of the state across its territory, and features of
subnational authoritarianism.
Original languageEnglish (US)
Number of pages58
StatePublished - May 25 2016

Fingerprint

violence
election
economic elite
land policy
authoritarianism
political elite
Colombia
allies
inhabitant
municipality
inclusion
regression
interpretation
society
evidence
Group

Cite this

Vargas Duque, J. F., Fergusson, L., Ruiz-Guarin, A., & Querubin, P. (2016). The Real Winner´s Curse.
Vargas Duque, Juan Fernando ; Fergusson, Leopoldo ; Ruiz-Guarin, Alejandro ; Querubin, Pablo . / The Real Winner´s Curse. 2016.
@techreport{bdd290dd92fc4a548afe0abc16c20efc,
title = "The Real Winner´s Curse",
abstract = "We study the effect on violence of the arrival of previously excluded groups (in particular,left-leaning parties) to local executive office in Colombian municipalities. Using a regressiondiscontinuity approach, we show that while violence from left-wing guerrillas and the governmentis unaffected when the left wins mayoral elections, attacks by right-wing paramilitariesincrease by about four to five per 100,000 inhabitants, almost a tripling relative to the samplemean and close to 80{\%}-100{\%} of a standard deviation. We interpret this increase in violenceas a de facto reaction of traditional political and economic elites trying to counteract the increasein de jure power of outsiders after they win office. Consistent with this interpretation,we find that the surge in violence is concentrated in the year of the subsequent electionsand as a result left wing incumbents enjoy an incumbency disadvantage larger than otherincumbent parties in Colombia. We also find (more tentative evidence) that the left implementsland policies that are threatening to the most notorious allies of paramilitaries: largelandowners. These effects highlight the unintended risks of political inclusion in societieswith weak institutions, an uneven presence of the state across its territory, and features ofsubnational authoritarianism.",
author = "{Vargas Duque}, {Juan Fernando} and Leopoldo Fergusson and Alejandro Ruiz-Guarin and Pablo Querubin",
year = "2016",
month = "5",
day = "25",
language = "English (US)",
type = "WorkingPaper",

}

Vargas Duque, JF, Fergusson, L, Ruiz-Guarin, A & Querubin, P 2016 'The Real Winner´s Curse'.

The Real Winner´s Curse. / Vargas Duque, Juan Fernando; Fergusson, Leopoldo; Ruiz-Guarin, Alejandro; Querubin, Pablo .

2016.

Research output: Working paper

TY - UNPB

T1 - The Real Winner´s Curse

AU - Vargas Duque, Juan Fernando

AU - Fergusson, Leopoldo

AU - Ruiz-Guarin, Alejandro

AU - Querubin, Pablo

PY - 2016/5/25

Y1 - 2016/5/25

N2 - We study the effect on violence of the arrival of previously excluded groups (in particular,left-leaning parties) to local executive office in Colombian municipalities. Using a regressiondiscontinuity approach, we show that while violence from left-wing guerrillas and the governmentis unaffected when the left wins mayoral elections, attacks by right-wing paramilitariesincrease by about four to five per 100,000 inhabitants, almost a tripling relative to the samplemean and close to 80%-100% of a standard deviation. We interpret this increase in violenceas a de facto reaction of traditional political and economic elites trying to counteract the increasein de jure power of outsiders after they win office. Consistent with this interpretation,we find that the surge in violence is concentrated in the year of the subsequent electionsand as a result left wing incumbents enjoy an incumbency disadvantage larger than otherincumbent parties in Colombia. We also find (more tentative evidence) that the left implementsland policies that are threatening to the most notorious allies of paramilitaries: largelandowners. These effects highlight the unintended risks of political inclusion in societieswith weak institutions, an uneven presence of the state across its territory, and features ofsubnational authoritarianism.

AB - We study the effect on violence of the arrival of previously excluded groups (in particular,left-leaning parties) to local executive office in Colombian municipalities. Using a regressiondiscontinuity approach, we show that while violence from left-wing guerrillas and the governmentis unaffected when the left wins mayoral elections, attacks by right-wing paramilitariesincrease by about four to five per 100,000 inhabitants, almost a tripling relative to the samplemean and close to 80%-100% of a standard deviation. We interpret this increase in violenceas a de facto reaction of traditional political and economic elites trying to counteract the increasein de jure power of outsiders after they win office. Consistent with this interpretation,we find that the surge in violence is concentrated in the year of the subsequent electionsand as a result left wing incumbents enjoy an incumbency disadvantage larger than otherincumbent parties in Colombia. We also find (more tentative evidence) that the left implementsland policies that are threatening to the most notorious allies of paramilitaries: largelandowners. These effects highlight the unintended risks of political inclusion in societieswith weak institutions, an uneven presence of the state across its territory, and features ofsubnational authoritarianism.

UR - https://economia.uniandes.edu.co/components/com_booklibrary/ebooks/dcede2017-05.pdf

M3 - Working paper

BT - The Real Winner´s Curse

ER -

Vargas Duque JF, Fergusson L, Ruiz-Guarin A, Querubin P. The Real Winner´s Curse. 2016 May 25.