Trees and Crime in Bogota, Colombia: Is the link an ecosystem disservice or service?

Francisco Javier Escobedo, Nicola Clerici, Christina L. Staudhammer, Alejandro Feged Rivadeneira, Germán Tovar Corzo, Juan Camilo Bohorquez

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

There is a perception that increased forest cover and density in urban contexts is associated with increased criminality. But, this complex relationship between urban vegetation, crime, ecosystem services (ES) and disservices (ED), has been little studied in low and middle income countries. This study’s aim was to statistically determine if specific structural and socioeconomic characteristics of urban treescapes were related to crime occurrence, considered an ED, in a major Latin American city. We used spatial and statistical analyses of a public tree inventory, homicide occurrence, and available geospatial data to analyze if urban treescape, demographic, and socioeconomic variables were related to the incidence of homicides in Neotropical Bogota, Colombia. First, a generalized linear model indicated that fewer homicides occurred in public treescapes with taller trees and higher tree density. In contrast, the amount of overall green space and average tree basal area were not significant predictors of homicide occurrence. Second, a geographically weighted regression model indicated that
the inclusion of tree basal area rendered tree height insignificant, and that higher basal areas were associated with fewer homicides. Thus, both models indicated that increased tree density and size were actually associated with lower homicide occurrences. The amount of public green areas was however, not significantly related to homicide occurrence. Results indicate that in general, Bogota´s treescapes provided overall net ES as opposed to ED in terms of crime. Findings could be used to develop land use policies and management practices that increase the overall provision and demand for ES from urban forests.
Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)583-592
Number of pages10
JournalLand Use Policy
Volume78
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 2 2018

Cite this

Escobedo, Francisco Javier ; Clerici, Nicola ; Staudhammer, Christina L. ; Feged Rivadeneira, Alejandro ; Corzo, Germán Tovar ; Bohorquez, Juan Camilo. / Trees and Crime in Bogota, Colombia: Is the link an ecosystem disservice or service?. In: Land Use Policy. 2018 ; Vol. 78. pp. 583-592.
@article{b9f9dfbd456e4917b2504f1c2cbcd0dc,
title = "Trees and Crime in Bogota, Colombia: Is the link an ecosystem disservice or service?",
abstract = "There is a perception that increased forest cover and density in urban contexts is associated with increased criminality. But, this complex relationship between urban vegetation, crime, ecosystem services (ES) and disservices (ED), has been little studied in low and middle income countries. This study’s aim was to statistically determine if specific structural and socioeconomic characteristics of urban treescapes were related to crime occurrence, considered an ED, in a major Latin American city. We used spatial and statistical analyses of a public tree inventory, homicide occurrence, and available geospatial data to analyze if urban treescape, demographic, and socioeconomic variables were related to the incidence of homicides in Neotropical Bogota, Colombia. First, a generalized linear model indicated that fewer homicides occurred in public treescapes with taller trees and higher tree density. In contrast, the amount of overall green space and average tree basal area were not significant predictors of homicide occurrence. Second, a geographically weighted regression model indicated thatthe inclusion of tree basal area rendered tree height insignificant, and that higher basal areas were associated with fewer homicides. Thus, both models indicated that increased tree density and size were actually associated with lower homicide occurrences. The amount of public green areas was however, not significantly related to homicide occurrence. Results indicate that in general, Bogota´s treescapes provided overall net ES as opposed to ED in terms of crime. Findings could be used to develop land use policies and management practices that increase the overall provision and demand for ES from urban forests.",
author = "Escobedo, {Francisco Javier} and Nicola Clerici and Staudhammer, {Christina L.} and {Feged Rivadeneira}, Alejandro and Corzo, {Germ{\'a}n Tovar} and Bohorquez, {Juan Camilo}",
year = "2018",
month = "11",
day = "2",
doi = "10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.07.029",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "78",
pages = "583--592",
journal = "Land Use Policy",
issn = "0264-8377",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

Trees and Crime in Bogota, Colombia: Is the link an ecosystem disservice or service? / Escobedo, Francisco Javier; Clerici, Nicola; Staudhammer, Christina L.; Feged Rivadeneira, Alejandro; Corzo, Germán Tovar; Bohorquez, Juan Camilo.

In: Land Use Policy, Vol. 78, 02.11.2018, p. 583-592.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Trees and Crime in Bogota, Colombia: Is the link an ecosystem disservice or service?

AU - Escobedo, Francisco Javier

AU - Clerici, Nicola

AU - Staudhammer, Christina L.

AU - Feged Rivadeneira, Alejandro

AU - Corzo, Germán Tovar

AU - Bohorquez, Juan Camilo

PY - 2018/11/2

Y1 - 2018/11/2

N2 - There is a perception that increased forest cover and density in urban contexts is associated with increased criminality. But, this complex relationship between urban vegetation, crime, ecosystem services (ES) and disservices (ED), has been little studied in low and middle income countries. This study’s aim was to statistically determine if specific structural and socioeconomic characteristics of urban treescapes were related to crime occurrence, considered an ED, in a major Latin American city. We used spatial and statistical analyses of a public tree inventory, homicide occurrence, and available geospatial data to analyze if urban treescape, demographic, and socioeconomic variables were related to the incidence of homicides in Neotropical Bogota, Colombia. First, a generalized linear model indicated that fewer homicides occurred in public treescapes with taller trees and higher tree density. In contrast, the amount of overall green space and average tree basal area were not significant predictors of homicide occurrence. Second, a geographically weighted regression model indicated thatthe inclusion of tree basal area rendered tree height insignificant, and that higher basal areas were associated with fewer homicides. Thus, both models indicated that increased tree density and size were actually associated with lower homicide occurrences. The amount of public green areas was however, not significantly related to homicide occurrence. Results indicate that in general, Bogota´s treescapes provided overall net ES as opposed to ED in terms of crime. Findings could be used to develop land use policies and management practices that increase the overall provision and demand for ES from urban forests.

AB - There is a perception that increased forest cover and density in urban contexts is associated with increased criminality. But, this complex relationship between urban vegetation, crime, ecosystem services (ES) and disservices (ED), has been little studied in low and middle income countries. This study’s aim was to statistically determine if specific structural and socioeconomic characteristics of urban treescapes were related to crime occurrence, considered an ED, in a major Latin American city. We used spatial and statistical analyses of a public tree inventory, homicide occurrence, and available geospatial data to analyze if urban treescape, demographic, and socioeconomic variables were related to the incidence of homicides in Neotropical Bogota, Colombia. First, a generalized linear model indicated that fewer homicides occurred in public treescapes with taller trees and higher tree density. In contrast, the amount of overall green space and average tree basal area were not significant predictors of homicide occurrence. Second, a geographically weighted regression model indicated thatthe inclusion of tree basal area rendered tree height insignificant, and that higher basal areas were associated with fewer homicides. Thus, both models indicated that increased tree density and size were actually associated with lower homicide occurrences. The amount of public green areas was however, not significantly related to homicide occurrence. Results indicate that in general, Bogota´s treescapes provided overall net ES as opposed to ED in terms of crime. Findings could be used to develop land use policies and management practices that increase the overall provision and demand for ES from urban forests.

U2 - 10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.07.029

DO - 10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.07.029

M3 - Article

VL - 78

SP - 583

EP - 592

JO - Land Use Policy

JF - Land Use Policy

SN - 0264-8377

ER -